[dave]

Whilst frying eggs on the rock at Froggatt this afternoon we spotted that someone has had a go the start holds of Joe's Slab, looks a right mess.



They've also knocked off also a couple of smaller edges further left - thankfully not affecting any of the main problems.

Wouldn't have thought this was climbers, probably knobheads? Anyway, if you're out and about in the peak keep your eyes open.

[Johnny Brown]

Worst I've seen since the stuff at RHS. Be interesting to get any reports as to when it was done, it's very hard to imagine it was anyone but climbers.

[Falling Down]

 

[etjoset]

Yes, this is a disgrace. The chipped holds were there by midday on Sunday 14th October and were clearly made by repeated hammer blows, possibly using a chisel judging by their form. Other climbers were speculating that they might not have been there when they had arrived first thing that morning, though I got the impression that no one was really sure.

[Bonjoy]

We saw this noon yesterday. Also some damage to the base of Greengut which looked equally fresh (prised flake and chipped off corner). Smacked of random knobhead work.
Some twat trying out their brand new geology hammer? 

[SA Chris]

Why would climbers make holds worse? I reckon some arse with a hammer.

[SamT]

 

[tomtom]

Why would climbers make holds worse? I reckon some arse with a hammer.

+1

[mark s]

looks like a 'karma' style attack,maybe someone with a grudge aganst climbers or a climber.
agree with the why make it harder posts

[dave]

The irony is it doesn't even make it any harder.

[Andy F]

Why would climbers make holds worse? I reckon some arse with a hammer.

So... a arse with a hammer walking along a gritstone edge decides to whack away indiscriminately. Geologist?

[andy_e]

I think it was more likely a geochemist actually.

[Andy F]

I think it was more likely a geochemist actually.

Why would a geochemist have any interest in some poncy soft rock? 

[andy_e]

 

It doesn't look like a good sample piece would have broken off and I doubt most sensible geologists would want to take a sample, coated in chalk, of an entirely unremarkable sandstone.

[SA Chris]

entirely unremarkable sandstone.

Now that's fighting talk.

[tomtom]

entirely unremarkable sandstone.

Now that's fighting talk.

Its not even been called yet!

Maybe Dobbin has a new pscientific method for determining the angle of the tortoises trotter?

[leeroy]

We saw this noon yesterday. Also some damage to the base of Greengut which looked equally fresh (prised flake and chipped off corner). Smacked of random knobhead work.
Some twat trying out their brand new geology hammer? 

that scar was on green gut isnt that recent (if were thinking same on, about a foot square near bottom.). noticed when first trying sole power a few weeks ago.

browns slab chipping looks similar to the damage at the bottom of power of the dark side a couple of years ago.

[dr_botnik]

Yeh, was there on sat 27th and had to chastise some kids throwing rocks down greengut, bit off putting when your climbing routes without a lid... noticed the damage (big flake chipped off) but thought at the time it wasn't their fault, can't see this being from a similar incident, can only be chipping 

[SamT]

actually - looking at the pics (haven't seen it in the flesh yet), could it not have been done by a falling stone, i.e. - free falls, hitting the hold (and the rock just above) knocking the edge of the hold off.

(I was at bowden doors of the summer and some tits had made a royal mess of the clean black wall below crater maker by hurling rocks at it repeatedly till all the rocks were smashed to bits  )

[Gritlad]

Think its most likely dickheads throwing stones. Would a falling rock not hit the ledge above first as it rolls down the slab? Could also be someone in a tantrum with a hex or a big cam hits the rock or similar in rage?

[mark20]

Had a look yesterday morning, one of the 'chips' improves a small foothold / smear used on the foot traverse and problem left of Joe's Slab. Which make me think it was done delibrated by a climber.

[dave]

actually - looking at the pics (haven't seen it in the flesh yet), could it not have been done by a falling stone,

Exceptionally unlikely, unless it was a massive stone of a much harder rock than grit, plus due to the angle of the rock no falling rock would hit these holds.

[SA Chris]

some tits had made a royal mess of the clean black wall below crater maker

Are you sure they were tits, and not swallows with coconuts?

[SamT]

    ( I wish I'd been there to see them  )

[tomtom]

Magpies with disco balls..