11
news / Re: The inevitable E grade thread
« Last post by andy moles on Today at 06:02:37 pm »Bit of an absurd comparison to make, was what I was getting at. At least apples and oranges are both similarly-sized spherical fruit.
Apologies, re-reading your post I agree with the general point.
Though my impression is that hard E-grades are not always graded for the hypothetical on-sight attempt - listening to what various people climbing those routes have said or written, it doesn't always seem to be a consideration. In Dave Mac's recent-ish video on how he grades routes, for example, he didn't even touch on it.