I'm not sure what you are saying (as usual) but it sounds like a criticism of petejh. Doylo knows who the belayer was, had his contact details and also knows him personally. petejh didn't.
Also emails from strangers don't elicit the same response (if any) as emails from mates.
To save anyone ploughing through the UKC thread (which you can only do if you are registered) what petejh said was:
