UKBouldering.com
the shizzle => get involved: access, environment, BMC => Topic started by: Seb on March 15, 2016, 08:29:34 pm
-
I dropped into anston after work today to see if apprentice wall was dry and found a sign saying amongst other things no climbing. Anyone know anything about the situation?
-
An official looking one or a homemade one?
-
I dropped into anston after work today to see if apprentice wall was dry and found a sign saying amongst other things no climbing. Anyone know anything about the situation?
Was the sign at apprentice or by the main area?
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
-
We need details
-
Official looking one at the entrance by apprentice wall didn't look at the main entrance.
-
Any symbols sugggesting its the rail network?
-
Nope it looked like parish council sssi related stuff.
-
I thought the parish coucil had been contacted a while a go and had an understanding of what climbers where doing in the woods. May be worth contacting the BMC with an email?
-
Could someone get a picture of the sign for starters please? Ta.
-
Could someone get a picture of the sign for starters please? Ta.
Seb has a pretty good reputation within the climbing community due to having been witnessed reading stuff before, even his very partaking of this forum strongly suggests he can read, so I for one see the call for photographic evidence way ott ;)
I'll get me coat.
Sent from my E5823 using Tapatalk
-
https://www.dropbox.com/s/rdejy08s3b4y42i/IMG_20160321_141030558.jpg?dl=0
Photo of the sign if that works...
-
https://www.dropbox.com/s/rdejy08s3b4y42i/IMG_20160321_141030558.jpg?dl=0
Photo of the sign if that works...
(https://photos-6.dropbox.com/t/2/AADbhWuCZymY2aR8vT-ieBg2FS4BD769WXS21wc9Uz3peA/12/69255809/jpeg/32x32/3/1458590400/0/2/IMG_20160321_141030558.jpg/EILY6zUYvc0BIAcoBw/tdsHqj5Hk7uKR_mQgoC8zZqVb5RkZon2cKjiJdcmqiI?size_mode=3&size=1600x1200)
-
Is there an access rep for that area? Seems like a call to that number is needed. Climbing as carried out by responsible users does not contravene either of the stated clauses. It's also arguable whether climbing counts as "in the control of the owner occupier". Plus the designation is principally with regard to the woodland rather than the crags.
-
It's probably you yoot. Might be worth speaking to Dolph first.
The sign is a fairly typical kneejerk response to folk's assumption that nature reserves and climbing are mutually exclusive, including NE staff. Typically dogwalking is far more harmful.
-
I talked to dolph. He sugested talking to 'rob' at the bmc
-
Anyone know his email address or phone number cos ill contact him. Googled his name but couldnt find a contact address
-
It is Natural England who have the say so. My experience is it depends entirely who you deal with. Some are sensible, others less so. I get the impression it is a lack of experience/ confidence that results in over-cautious restrictions. Likewise such folk are easily steam-rollered by management when a big event crops up.
You get a very good insight into their job/ the process on the recently repeated Tales from the National Parks (http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episodes/b016n129), particularly the Lakes one.
SSSI designation carries no automatic restrictions as such but that is the perception. The full notifications are available on the web, and are usually well worth reading as you could easily scotch such nonsense as nesting Herring Gulls - they would not be likely to be mentioned. In my experience sites notified for botanical interest rarely involve species on the crag itself, and sites notified for geological interest are unlikely to be damaged by climbing. Being pre-armed with this information makes discussions much easier - most NE staff will assume you are totally ignorant of nature.
Most geologists see climbing as positive if anything, keeping the exposure clear. I was a little surprised to hear the relevant geologist couldn't care less about the bolts in Malham, but then it's a subject that tends to breed scant regard for the petty affairs of man.
This post from JB a while ago leaps to mind.
-
Ive talked to someone from the BMC about this so hopefully they will contact anston parish council/ whoever
-
Any news on this?
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
-
Any news on this?
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
Ring Rob Dyer at the BMC if you are keen for an update - I know he is on with it
-
Any news on this?
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
Ring Rob Dyer at the BMC if you are keen for an update - I know he is on with it
Do you have an email address for him?
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
-
Do you have an email address for him?
Is your google broken?
robd@thebmc.co.uk
https://www.thebmc.co.uk/bmc-staff-list
-
A few emails have been round the access team, but no progress as yet. Dolph is the most informed and has only just got back from Macedonia.
Don't stop climbing there; if confronted stay polite and explain you are not breaking any laws - many crags are SSSIs and NE are not opposed to climbing here. Climbers are not drinking, lighting fires, defecating and are likely discouraging others from doing so.
-
Is there an access rep for that area? Seems like a call to that number is needed. Climbing as carried out by responsible users does not contravene either of the stated clauses. It's also arguable whether climbing counts as "in the control of the owner occupier". Plus the designation is principally with regard to the woodland rather than the crags.
Having done some reading up on the SSSI notification, it seems that the protected species of interest are all part of the woodland floor, and are not specific to the limetone outcrops.
Sent from my GT-I9195 using Tapatalk
-
This is on the agenda for tomorrow's Peak area meet at Grindleford. Be good if activists are there
-
I spoke to Rob Dyer last week and he was sure that there was mo objection from Natural England on SSSI grounds. So it's a question of educating/ winning over local objectors.
-
mo objection
mo problems?
-
There was no way I could make that BMC meeting unfortunately.
What was the outcome of those deliberations?
-
It was just a case of expanding on the above information. No problem with SSSI status, not mo obvs.
Winning over the parish council is not likely to happen overnight. A track record of responsible access is always the most powerful argument. So keep going and be polite if confronted.
-
This sign was up at the main gate on the A57 today, not sure if this is a recent development. I had no issues whilst I was there, and only saw one dog walker all day.
(https://scontent-lhr3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xfp1/t31.0-8/fr/cp0/e15/q65/13123233_10102474903916489_3140916658206454094_o.jpg)
-
Well Natural England have given their consent so crack on.
-
Any updates on getting these signs removed? Feels abit shit climbing here, with no climbing signs at every entrance to the woods