UKBouldering.com

the shizzle => shootin' the shit => food & drink => Topic started by: dave on August 26, 2008, 01:45:52 pm

Title: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on August 26, 2008, 01:45:52 pm
Alright you rimlickers

It just struck me that there's never been a real hub on here for recomendations and discussion of the relative merits of various peak (and peripheral) pubs vis a vis the standard of eating experience you can expect. This came to me after recently having either firsthand or secondhand tales of previsouly good pubs getting shit and vice versa.

So heads up, and everyone chip in with some knowledge. I'll start the ball rolling with:

The Millstone, Hathersage: I was always used to like this place, but lately it seems to have gone off the boil, like they've given up putting any effort in. The specials board never changes for a start. Famous for its sausage&mash mix&match combos, but the last one I had was shit. 2 tiny hard venison sausages (looked pre-cooked then quicky reheated, I'm sure they used to be bigger and better), a pile of what was described on the menu as "bubble & squeak" but was really just mash mixed with some bits of veg, not fried at all, bearing all the hallmarks of just having had 2 mins in the microwave, all sat in a large "yorkshire pudding" of the horrible brittle frozen type. And not cheap. And theres no slouchable seating. (That said, the ale is good with some peak locals.)

The Little John, Hathersage: Not the finest food going but decent, unashamedly massive portions and fairly cheap = very cheerful. Plus a good range of ales. Comfy seating.

The Dore Moor, Sheffield: last time we waited over 2 hours for shit food and left without paying. Avoid.

Any more for any more?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: jfw on August 26, 2008, 01:53:01 pm
the grouse near froggat

do good simple pub stodge, real fire (greati n winter)

also do a cheaper small portion if you don't want phelps/feltz size portions

nice deuchars IPA
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on August 26, 2008, 01:55:55 pm
Think The Millstone's changed hands or something. I know the guys who ran the Terrace restaurant when we had our wedding meal there two years ago aren't there anymore. This could explain the downturn in standards.

The Red Lion in Litton - only been for food once on a Sunday quite a while ago. It was cheap and very good in an Old Skool sunday roast style. I can't imagine it's altered much as Litton is in some sort of 1930s time warp.

The Fox House is fucking shit now. Used to be a great pub.

The Chequers is expensive (for a pub) but the last time I went it was still well worth it. I've never had a bad meal there.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: ChrisC on August 26, 2008, 01:57:28 pm
Anglers Rest, Millers Dale - Good food - Pie night especially on a Thursday eve, finishes a bit early if your at the Tor though.

Red Lion, Litton - Top pub, top food, friendlt staff.

Three Stags Head, Wardlow Mires - A Shit pub in all respects.  Unless you like the Countryside Alliance, grumpy service, beer that tastes like it was made from mud and an air that smells like the Yorvik Viking Center.

Re The Grouse, it's what the Fox House should be (or was...) Totally aggree with the above - Its a toss up between the Red Lion and The Grouse for the best pub in the Peak for me.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on August 26, 2008, 02:03:16 pm
I think scouse told me the Fox House was shite recently.

Chequers was always good when I've been (i.e. when parents were paying...).

Eyre Arms, Hassop: Not been recently but was always very good food, a bit expensive but worth it on occaision. Very cosy setup.

Angler's Rest, Miller's Dale: Again I've not been super recently but have always found it friendly, nice oldschool food and good beer previousy - hope its still the same. Got a walker's room for those in mucky boots. (just seen punter's post, great minds etc).

Was gonna ask if anyone had food at the 3slags heads? I always thought it was OK, might not be to everyone's tastes but at least its different, and I have never been able to fault the beer.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bubba on August 26, 2008, 02:08:12 pm
The Monsal Head Hotel - Used to be quite good but the last couple of times it's been pants. Last time I went there I ordered some sort of Spanish salad but all i got was a lot of tired, limp lettuce and greens, some flavourless tinned artichokes and a few measly bits of not very good chorizo. Very unsatisfying.

The Chequers Inn - Always been good.

The Moon - Not bad but nothing great.

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on August 26, 2008, 02:15:37 pm
The Little John, utterly shit how they managed to get into the good beer guide amazes me.
Red Lion and The three Stags heads are from memory top pubs.
The Grouse, fine beer but never eaten there,
The Scotsman's pack is shit.
The Robin Hood below Birchens has been taken over and the beer is now drinkable, don't know about the food.
Norfolk Arms, I haven't been in since the makeover but I reckon it will be bust in the new year.
The Fox House, it's a plastic pub so you know what to expect.
The Miners Standard, still a good country boozer
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: ChrisC on August 26, 2008, 02:24:20 pm
Ok, maybe a bit harsh on the Three Stags - but when you phone rings as you walk into a pub and someone demands a quid for "Charity" without so much as an explanation, and then says that "Charity" is the Countryside Alliance they can fuck off.   Its hardly cancer research.  I believe a similar incident happened to Irish Si and some friends a few years ago where he locked them in the pub until they agreed to pay for their beer?

The Bulls Head, Ashford in the Water  - Never eaten, but supposed to be good, nice atmosphere and nice beer.

The Moon - I think it changed hands recently, supposed to do a good curry night now (Tuesdays?).

Re The Little John, I've never forgiven them for serving partially frozen lasange, taking it away for 15mins, and then bringing it back nuclear hot with cold chips.

I ate at the Robin Hood last weekend - Reasonable food at resonable prices.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: r-man on August 26, 2008, 02:34:53 pm
Three Stags Head, Wardlow Mires - A Shit pub in all respects.  Unless you like the Countryside Alliance, grumpy service, beer that tastes like it was made from mud and an air that smells like the Yorvik Viking Center.

So wrong. Best pub in the peak. Best if you camp there for a night, then you can stay long enough to enjoy the music, and whatever else happens to happen. Impromptu folk dancing lessons (including a traditional arse kicking dance) made for one of my favourite nights there.

I was stung by the quid for phone tax once. I argued but then paid. Countryside Alliance is probably something they made up to wind you up. It's worth a quid just because it's such a brilliantly obnoxious country rule.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on August 26, 2008, 02:43:01 pm
I must admit I can see why you'd be put off. No amount of folk dancing would compensate for someone trying to force me to donate money to the Countryside Alliance, joke or not.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: cofe on August 26, 2008, 02:46:03 pm
i don't remember the fox house ever being any good. same chain as dore moor, no? the latter is v shit.

red lion litton good - went the other week. beware they don't welcome people with babies or kids under 6 - weird.

i like the grouse nr froggatt. simple and honest and a good fire going when it's cold.

travellers rest nr buxton/roaches is good. not eaten there for a couple of yrs though innit.

used to like millstone for sausages and mona lisa smoking reefer in toilet but got ill from eating there last time so haven't been back. that must be over a yr ago etc.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on August 26, 2008, 02:54:09 pm
beware they don't welcome people with babies or kids under 6

Shirley all babies are under 6 by deffinition?

I must admit I've always found the food in the Grouse to be "good" rather than amazing, but the whole ambiance of the place is alluring, and the location is a winner, you can pop out and solo tegness pinnacle while waiting for your main course. I just wish their range of beers was just a bit wider than just Banks and Deuchars IPA. Beware I think theres one day of the week they don't do food (if you're just turning up on spec), I think its mondays.

Another good one almost in the peak is The Sportsman at Lodge Moor. Good food, homely vibe. Popular too, so worth booking for a meal, especially on weekends.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on August 26, 2008, 02:54:26 pm
Sir William in Gridleford has always satisfied me. Good food, good service, nice views, tables outside for when its not raining. I think they are due to do some refurbishment work soon?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: grimer on August 26, 2008, 02:58:16 pm
The Strines is a nice pub for drinking in, nice atmosphere, although not thought the food was great.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on August 26, 2008, 03:00:26 pm
Perhaps delineation with regards to beer quality and food quality is required....


PubBeer QualityFood QualityOther Comments
Fox HousePassable, varying selection of real alesOver-priced and genericUseful car-park for Burbage South
Millstone InnGood & varied selection of real alesOnly eaten once a month or so ago and the meal was enjoyed by allClosest pub to Millstone
Little JohnBeer selection isn't great, but its okMassive portions of what generally appears to be freshly prepared mealsGood value for those on a budget
Yorkshire Bridge InnCan't comment, haven't eaten thereFriendly Place, nearest pub to Bamford Edge
Ladybower InnNot much choice on alesFoods home-cooked, but nothing specialBetter off at the Yorkshire Bridge
Strines Moor InnFair selection of alesN/A (Haven't eaten there)Nearest pub to Dovestones/Back Tor
Bridge Inn, CurbarGood selection of beerN/A (Haven't eaten there)
The MoonGood selection of well kept beersN/A (Haven't eaten there)Very friendly, curry nights on Tuedays (till 21.00)
Three StagsOnly drank there once, and had shandy as I was driving, so can't commentN/A (Haven't eaten there)Quite small, but camping available outside.
Monsal Head HotelNot a very wide selection of ales, but mostly local brewsN/A (Haven't eaten there)Very slow service
Rising SunExcellent varied selection of well kept beersN/A (doesn't really serve food)Good alternative when returning from Burbage/Stanage if you don't mind cutting through Fulwood
Chequers InndDon't remember selection of beersExcellent foodClosest pub to Froggat (depending on where you park), food is pricey though.
Grouse InnPassable selection of beers, generally well servedN/A (Haven't eaten there)Also close to Froggat (depending on where you live), seems to have strange opening hours (i.e. closed when I tried calling in once!)
Robin Hood InnGood well kept beers (now0Haven't eaten there for a while, but used to be good and a sensible selection of sandwichesClosest pub to Birchen, sells nice honey behind the bar. No longer has the naval theme.
Peacock InnSmall selection of beers, generally well served.Very nice food, but quite priceyOn the way home from Gardoms/Baslow/Birchen/Curbar.  Entertainment on Saturdays/Sundays watching boy-racers pull whellies on their motorbikes.

Here's a sample table for others to use, simply quote this post then copy and paste the following and fill in the relevant sections (if you can be bothered)...

PubBeer QualityFood QualityOther Comments
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on August 26, 2008, 03:14:46 pm
The rising sun does do food (http://www.risingsunsheffield.co.uk/rising_sun_food.html), not that I've ever had it. Superb pub.

The Ladybower used to do brilliant food - had a few very good meals there, and early last December I went with the shortie and we had the xmas menu, it was amazing. however recently I've had reports of it being totally shit. Was residing squarely in mediocreville last time i went early this summer.

Yorkshire Bridge food is good, not amazing but pretty consistent, and will give you a free basket of bread if you ask (always pays to read the menu fineprint....). Specials board regularly changes. Very good Copper Dragon ales - currently Golden Pippin and 1816, plus Old Peculiar and another one (bombadier?). Written (and illustrated) letter on the wall from Rolf Harris who ate there in 1998 praising the food, and was evidently so satiated he was unable to spell the name of the establishment correctly. Can you tell what it is yet?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on August 26, 2008, 03:19:32 pm
My mistake, only saw sandwich menu at lunch time the other day and didn't think it was worth mentioning.  Its now the nearest pub to where I'm working and will no doubt become a regular  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: SA Chris on August 26, 2008, 03:44:31 pm
i don't remember the fox house ever being any good. same chain as dore moor, no?

Last time I went in there was 1997. Had great food, loads of beer, and pitched the tent out the back. It all went south not long after, never been back.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bubba on August 26, 2008, 03:59:43 pm

Yeah, the Fox House used to be a real pub a long time ago.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: cofe on August 26, 2008, 04:20:44 pm
i used to walk past it en route to burb sth after getting off the bus from sheff back in '97. can't remember going in. it says a lot for a pub when its best feature is its car park.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Fiend on August 26, 2008, 04:55:31 pm
Food-wise, The Plough @ Hathersage, Derwentwater something or other @ Calver and The Barrel @ well wherever it is, the big ridge above Grindleford, piss all over most of those, except the Chequers but they don't count as they're a bunch of snotty cunts in there.

In the South East Peak and slightly more upmarket, Le Mistral in Wirksworth is excellent.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on August 26, 2008, 05:10:49 pm
I've never been able to tally this "The Chequers is run by snotty cunts" attitude with the actual experience of eating / drinking there. I've been going for years and have only ever had good service and excellent food.

I guess others must have had bad experiences as it's an oft touted line. Maybe I've just been lucky.  :-\
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: cofe on August 26, 2008, 05:13:41 pm
the old bowling green in winster. (http://www.peakparkpub.co.uk/) remember it having good food and beer. plus they sell our books behind the bar. good stuff.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on August 26, 2008, 08:10:39 pm
We've eaten at the Strines quite a bit, always rated it. Not amazing but good home made pub grub. Their chips are rather special. Fox house is pretty souless nowdays but the food is alright.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bonjoy on August 26, 2008, 08:43:14 pm
I'll throw in a vote for The Plough in Grindleford.
The Gate in Brassington used to be amazing, but it's a few years since I last went.
The Devonshire Arms in Beeley - top food, excellent beer, roaring fire and on the way back from Cratcliffe. What could be better for post bouldering visit?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: fatkid2000 on August 26, 2008, 09:39:12 pm
I've always been disappointed by the Peaks Pubs, either the food is rubbish or the beer or more often than not both. I think the problem is that most of them don't really have to try very hard to get custom due to all the day tripping type visitors, look how busy the Fox House gets. The only place that's any good IMO on a regular basis has been Chequers and they've always been pleasant to me. The other place I've been taken to recently, by the MTB crowd Is 'The Crown' at Totley which does a nice pint & always seems busy on the food front but their pints are quite pricey, although its not really in the Peaks.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on August 26, 2008, 09:40:21 pm
One place I must mention is Rowley's at Baslow (http://www.rowleysrestaurant.co.uk/). Not really a pub now in the classic sense of the word but they do food and have a bar (nice Thorbridge ales). This place is pretty expen$ive but for a special occaision its very very very good food, and the staff are very helpful, and a slick but not poncy modern decor. I highly recommend it for anyone taking their shortie out for a treat. I think they have a cheaper early evening menu too.  Run by the Fischer's peeps so you know its all gravy.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bonjoy on August 26, 2008, 09:49:10 pm
Rowley's head Chef James Grant is a climber. Sound bloke and very passionate about his food. I haven't been since he took over but I'd imagine he'll be doing a good job.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Eddies on August 26, 2008, 10:05:47 pm
Plenty of nice pubs on the west side.

The New Inn in Flash is a great little pub and serves a few great real ales and the tucker is bob-on... proper farmers meals and there as cheap as ewt.
The Travellers Rest in Quarnford also does good home cooked food and serves real ales, and the Quiet Woman (or Fictitious female to the locals) in Earl Sterndale has localy brewed ales, sells goose and duck eggs with shit still on em and the pool table is 40p. Game is still legal tender there and if the hairy folk musicians arent there to entertain then the local banter is just as amusing!

Come on down, but dont stray off the path!!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on August 26, 2008, 10:25:27 pm
If some one else is paying or your expense account is on the healthy side I'd seriously recommend the Peacock in Rowsley (think £100 for lunch foir two with drinks a shade more for supper).

The Sir William is my local and a Hardy & Hansons so on the acceptable end of the plastic pub spectrum, albeit with a nice beer garden.

If you're on High Tor the only decent pub in Matlock Bath is the Temple Hotel, although 'the boat' in Cromford has re-opened after it went bust (and a deepl clean that was requried to say the laest) and is a top boozer and handy(ish) for Black Rocks.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Fiend on August 27, 2008, 09:17:02 am
I've always been disappointed by the Peaks Pubs, either the food is rubbish or the beer or more often than not both.

Possibly this thread will be useful to you then!!

Although I agree that having good food AND good beer is rarer than it should be.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: andy popp on August 27, 2008, 10:20:35 am
The only time I've been to the Quiet Woman in Earl Sterndale (pub sign: decapitated woman - nice!) they very obviously didn't want us in 'their' pub. This was a very long time ago though.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bubba on August 27, 2008, 12:20:34 pm
One place I must mention is Rowley's at Baslow (http://www.rowleysrestaurant.co.uk/). Not really a pub now in the classic sense of the word but they do food and have a bar (nice Thorbridge ales). This place is pretty expen$ive but for a special occaision its very very very good food, and the staff are very helpful, and a slick but not poncy modern decor. I highly recommend it for anyone taking their shortie out for a treat. I think they have a cheaper early evening menu too.  Run by the Fischer's peeps so you know its all gravy.

Yeah, more of a proper restaurant than pub-grub but it is really good. Excellent food without the extreme prices and extreme stuffiness of somewhere like it's parent Fischers.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: ChrisC on August 27, 2008, 10:19:15 pm
If you're on High Tor the only decent pub in Matlock Bath is the Temple Hotel, although 'the boat' in Cromford has re-opened after it went bust (and a deepl clean that was requried to say the laest) and is a top boozer and handy(ish) for Black Rocks.

Just over the top of High Tor is The White Lion, Starkholmes, which is an all round nice pub with friendly staff, good beer and good food.

Another vote for the Boat, it is better now its reopened and normal service resumed.  Though quiz night was always worth a laugh with the previous owner. 

While down this way The Bear, Alderwasley is worth a mention.  A bit of a gastro pub, but in a top location, top building and with top nosh too.  Cant remember the beer but I can't imagine it being shit.

Jug and Glass, Lea just changed hands so hopefully not gone down hill, but was very good before for all the right reasons.

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Somebody's Fool on August 28, 2008, 12:06:05 am
Although Earl Sterndale's Quiet Woman has received a heads up already, no one's yet mentioned their amazing pork pies. Undoubtedly its best feature (sign aside of course, but you can't eat that).
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bonjoy on August 28, 2008, 08:30:38 am
Quote
Just over the top of High Tor is The White Lion, Starkholmes, which is an all round nice pub with friendly staff, good beer and good food.
And boules behind the bar for playing out front!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: al on August 29, 2008, 09:21:02 pm
the main, old skool pub in youlgreave, what's it called - anyway can vouch for sunday's roast, more accurately the lamb, which was just that, a whole fucking locally rustled lamb, perched on top of a 'close encounters style' vegetable mountain - not sure about ale though
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tommytwotone on September 03, 2008, 05:31:23 pm
I'll put a vote in for The Chequers, not the cheapest but the food there has always been top notch then I've been.

Anyone been to The Bull at Foolow? Have heard a few reports that it's good, but never got round to trying it out.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on September 03, 2008, 10:56:40 pm
Been to The Bull at Foolow a few times, and won't go again.. Previously it wasn't bad - nice dining experience ina cosy room by candlelight, decent enough food off a blackboard and loads of choice provided you were there early enough.

Last time though, we'd made a booking by email that was confirmed, only to arrive and be told 'sorry, we don't have your booking and hence no table'

'we booked a month ago by email'

'well, the landlady's rubbish with email - you can sit here'

Where 'here' is the smallest table known to man, shoehorned into a corner behind two barstools upon which the UK and European Cigarette smoking champions are stationed..

Then when I am about to turn around and leave, miraculously a table comes free in the dining room. So we order the beef wellington and sit down... The 'beef wellington' arrives, a fucking great bit of tough cow, in a fucking thick great chewy crust like a proper pasty company effort, and with some kind of vile liver pate inside in place of the expected mushroomy goodness - which is great news for my then pregnant, shouldn't be eating pate anyway, gyal dem sugar. And the 'red wine gravy' is more like an oxo diluted with saline, with extra salt for the extra saltiness.

But that's pubs in the peak - british food culture, plenty of people will keep going there week after week and not have a clue the shite they shovel into their mouths, much less care. I'll cook it myself rather than paying those lazy, smug, filthy useless cunts a penny. And do it a lot fucking better for a tenth of the 'cost'. And not have to listen to a bunch of facile 'locals' discussing their pointless existence. I can get Big Brother from the comfort of my lounge, ta.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Fiend on September 05, 2008, 05:30:11 pm
plenty of people will keep going there week after week and not have a clue the shite they shovel into their mouths, much less care.

Although at least UKBers are bucking the trend with this thread :).

Nice rant. As both a contrast and a tangent may I offer The Cavendish Arms in Embsay which is not in the Peak District but is well placed for a post Crookrise / Deer Gallows / Eastby meal and for that matter not far off-route for all of Bardon Moor / Fell and The Lime. Picked on a random whim a few months back and a nice find: simple pub, simple pub food, but done how it should be. This is proper pub grub not proper gastropub grub. What's nice is it's all obviously freshly cooked and does exactly what it says on the tin: Garlic bread with cheese was a flagship for pub garlic bread with cheese, juicy, piping hot and drenched with garlic and mature cheese. Pork fillet with Wensleydale had a well-cooked chunk of pork with a fine slab of Wensleydale and good vegetables. Scampi and chips was properly fishy with good, chunky chips. Service was good and friendly in a "local" sort of way. I'd recommend it.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on September 05, 2008, 07:11:06 pm
Sir William in Grindleford has always satisfied me. Good food, good service, nice views, tables outside for when its not raining. I think they are due to do some refurbishment work soon?

Inspired by this thread, I took Mrs Starfish to the Sir William last weekend. It was great. Best roast (pork shoulder) dinner I've had out in a long while - perfect roast spuds and parsnips, good gravy - I would have chosen a fattier cut of meat, but it was cooked just right - decent sized portions. Neither of us drank any booze, so can't comment on that side of things. They start their refurbishment next week and expect to be finished before the end of September.
They have already replaced the white plastic tables and chairs outside with nice, solid wooden ones.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 21, 2008, 09:20:08 am
Have noticed the Sir Will'm is doing a 50% off ting at the moment:
http://www.sirwilliam.co.uk/opening-restaurant-offer-c30.html (http://www.sirwilliam.co.uk/opening-restaurant-offer-c30.html)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 21, 2008, 09:28:27 am
I'd also like to update on The Rising Sun, Fulwood. Have been in recently and had some very nice food, and the sunday carvery is good value and nice quality. obviously the beer is still well jackson.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on November 21, 2008, 10:21:11 am
and its 150yds away. boom.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Fiend on November 21, 2008, 10:59:27 am
Went there (Rising Sun) just the other night for the first time, very impressed, didn't know it was that good. Beer menu almost overwhelming.

Also noticed that the Lescar has come on a lot in the liquid refreshement stakes in the last few years. Started with a Franziskaner and thence onto a very nice and interesting Bonfire Toffee dark ale for mains.

Have noted SW for future reference.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Falling Down on November 21, 2008, 11:12:20 am
I can't remember if I've posted this before but if anyone is in the Chapel/Chinley/Whaley area then the best pub for beer and food in these parts is.

The Old Hall in Whitehough/Chinley. http://www.old-hall-inn.co.uk/ (http://www.old-hall-inn.co.uk/)

Daniel has a great range of guest ales and for the lager drinkers he has Budvar & Staropramen (sp?) on draught which are both mighty during the Summer months. 
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Houdini on November 24, 2008, 09:16:43 am
... Started with a Franziskaner ...

Think their hefe and dunkel are a bit touch-&-go, but the kristal (light, filtered) is great (though it's not a winter tipple).

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Will Hunt on November 24, 2008, 05:40:56 pm
Ye Olde Rock Inn is utterly horrible. Bad food, bad beer and bad climbers/walkers area. Have never failed to be disappointed in there.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Houdini on November 24, 2008, 05:43:21 pm
Obviously, you all know The (S)Heights in Llanber' is Dead?  Finally.


The food was fucking dire so no loss anyway.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on November 24, 2008, 05:52:13 pm
Stopped at the pub in Hassops (name eludes my memory recall at the moment) on Saturday on the way home and had a nice pint.  Didn't try the food and there weren't masses of hand-pulled beers but a possible alternative to regular haunts for people passing nearby.
Title: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: 205Chris on August 27, 2009, 08:20:35 pm
Following on from the Sheffield restaurant thread has anyone got any recommendations for pubs in the peak district that do decent evening meals?

Tried the Chequers at Froggatt and the Black Swan at Idridgehay and am after similar suggestions please.

Thanks.
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: GCW on August 27, 2009, 08:24:49 pm
Check out this thread (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9788.0.html).
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: Sloper on August 27, 2009, 08:32:09 pm
Since the other thread is dead,

avoid The Plough in Hathersage despite high prices I think the menu is likely to be sourced from 3663 or similar than from real ingredients.  My reason for this is that they were purportedly serving fresh crab on a Tuesday evening and their menu appears to exensive to be profitable with waste etc.

The Maynard in Grindleford is fine, if slightly over priced a la carte a few amuse bouche and a decent cellar would give it a real edge and a recommendation; the beer is always fine and the staff attentive and pleasant.

The Millstone seems to have nose dived and is if not in ICU financially I wouldn't be suprised if it wasn't seriously unwell.  In my recent experience best avoided.

Fox house, plastic pub, less than satisfactory beer, ready meals.  Having said that it's not the worst and has a good car park (damning with faint praise).

The robin hood (under Birchens, haven't eaten there but last time I can recall the new landlords were really good folk and making a good fist of a country boozer)

I'll stop now as my john dory starter is ready
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: Joepicalli on August 27, 2009, 09:11:31 pm
Druid at Birchover
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: Bonjoy on August 28, 2009, 08:39:52 am
The Peacock in Rowsley is very good if you're after the fine dining end of the pub food experience.
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: dave on August 28, 2009, 08:50:32 am
I might actually merge this onto the previous topic to keep it all in one place, that was the idea of the original one. http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9788.msg160180.html (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9788.msg160180.html)

any objections?
Title: Re: Peak pubs that do food recommendations please
Post by: slackline on August 28, 2009, 09:05:38 am
Seems to make sense
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on August 30, 2009, 09:01:07 pm
Today we went to The Ashford Arms in... Ashford in the Water. Gorgeous roast dinners, with perfect large Yorkshire puds of which they are justifiably proud. Everyone in the place looked to be enjoying their meals (all looked great).
Our friends are staying in Ashford for the weekend and said that the food at The Bull's Head was good, but it gets busy in the evenings, with all tables full by 6.30pm (they open at 6).
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Fiend on September 01, 2009, 01:33:24 pm
Yesterday we went to The Bull's Head in... Ashford in the Water. Rather nice food, with a delicious guinea fowl terrine starter and hearty if pricey main courses. Service was dilligent and swift, atmosphere was comfy, and there was still plenty of space at 7.30pm (they opened at 6.30).
Lagers recommended the Ashford Arms, alas they stopped serving food at 4pm on the bank holiday Monday.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: duncan on April 06, 2010, 10:37:18 am
Time to resurrect this thread for current peak foodie recommendations.  Ate at The Little John in Hathersage this weekend as it was 15 minutes walk from accommodation, serving food at 9.30pm on Easter Sunday, and I hadn't read this thread recently.

Food was vast in quantity and dire in quality.  I tend to stick to pub staples when in untested territory but even the haddock and chips was mediocre.  Beer was OK.

Where do you eat in Hathersage? 
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on April 06, 2010, 10:45:03 am
The Millstone Inn or The Scotsmans Pack.

The former being a bit out of town, but their sausage & mash mix-n-match is brilliant, and their specials board is usually pretty good.  Scotsmans Pack is more traditional fair.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 06, 2010, 10:50:50 am
I thought the millstone had gone to dogshit recent years, unless its changed hands again. Last sausage n mash i had there was garbage.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on April 06, 2010, 12:24:28 pm
The Millstone Inn or The Scotsmans Pack.

The former being a bit out of town, but their sausage & mash mix-n-match is brilliant, and their specials board is usually pretty good.  Scotsmans Pack is more traditional fair.

Last time I ate at the Scotsmans it had taken a downhill tumble. These days I just go to the littlejohn, at least then I know what i'll be getting. Ok food and lots of it.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Dolly on April 06, 2010, 01:25:25 pm
The last time I went to The Millstone it did have Kelham Island Pride of Sheffield on tap tho' - which was nice
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on April 06, 2010, 07:18:54 pm
Sadly the sir william hill in grindleford has missed the opportunity to survive . . . .again.

The beer is crap greene king and not well kept and expensive to boot.

The food is apparently poor in quality, small in portions and over priced eg £10 for fish and chips.

The staff are at least polite now which is a start but I don't see the place paying its way. 

Think the chequers without any of the good points of the chequers  :-[
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Drew on April 06, 2010, 07:24:15 pm
Ate at The Little John in Hathersage this weekend... Food was vast in quantity and dire in quality.

That's exactly what I've found the past few times I've eaten there. I've had a casserole that was so vinegary, I couldn't finish it (and that's saying something!). I always just eat at the Millstone. It's not amazing, but it's exactly what I'm after in terms of pub grub. Decent portions, and decent quality, for a fairly decent price. And it's always got a local beer or two on tap.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bonjoy on April 07, 2010, 12:51:08 pm

These days I just go to the littlejohn, at least then I know what i'll be getting. Ok food and lots of it.
What on earth does a Paul B do with a Littlejohn size meal, take home in a doggy-bag and liquidize to make a month's supply of cut-price protein shake?  ;)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 07, 2010, 12:55:14 pm
He just has a sachet of tartare sauce.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on April 07, 2010, 01:06:51 pm

These days I just go to the littlejohn, at least then I know what i'll be getting. Ok food and lots of it.
What on earth does a Paul B do with a Littlejohn size meal, take home in a doggy-bag and liquidize to make a month's supply of cut-price protein shake?  ;)

You've got me. Nat and I shared last time.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: jfw on April 07, 2010, 01:36:57 pm
i rate the grouse for simple, "local to shef" peak pub food - greene king IPA is OK there, good simple food, smaller (cheaper) portion available (to justify subsequent pudding splurge), nice fire.

agree with previous comments about naff sausage and mash at the millstone.

have had 1 nice/ok one ok/naff at the norfolk arms,

would definiely recommend the red lion at litton (not so local to home, but good if you've been on the lime) - had amazing home cooked ham egg and chips there - Yum!

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 07, 2010, 01:41:37 pm
would definiely recommend the red lion at litton

Yeah this place very good. Not been since the anklebiter arrival, I'm sure I saw a sign up there saying they weren't really down with people bringing binlids in, which is a shame.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on April 07, 2010, 02:37:54 pm
would definiely recommend the red lion at litton

Yeah this place very good. Not been since the anklebiter arrival, I'm sure I saw a sign up there saying they weren't really down with people bringing binlids in, which is a shame.

Had a great post lime pint there after some tor tickage.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 07, 2010, 02:45:27 pm
What? There's only one place to celebrate a tor tick, and that's elliots chippy in tideswell.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on April 07, 2010, 02:48:53 pm
You're right The Red Lion don't let kids in but if it's nice you can sit outside. Good pub.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: duncan on April 07, 2010, 03:42:58 pm
Thanks all.  I'm surprised there is not somewhere better in a place as large and affluent as Hathersage.  Perhaps with so much holiday trade standards don't need to be that high to stay in business.  Will have to designate a driver in future by the sound of it.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 07, 2010, 03:56:37 pm
If i was stuck in 'sage I recon I'd go to the Little John all the same. OK its not best quality, but its tollerable and it would still be reasonable value even if the portions were half their current size. I once had a big treacle sponge pudding in a big bowl full off custard, then was given and entire gravy boat full of auxiliary custard! The guy told me they basically don't make any profit off the food, its just there to keep the place busy and get traffic who buy drinks, which I don't remember as being especially expensive my peak standards anyway.  They also have a few decent local non-mainstream ales on too.

If you're gonna drive try the yorkshire bridge at bamford too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on April 07, 2010, 04:14:06 pm
I've not eaten there so can't comment but what about the Plough Inn (http://www.theploughinn-hathersage.co.uk/) just outside Hathersage on the road to Grindleford?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: cofe on April 07, 2010, 04:18:50 pm
the consensus seems to be 'don't go to hathersage'. the other recommendations are hardly a long way away.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on April 07, 2010, 04:23:51 pm
Yes, but the Plough Inn is walkable from Hatersage and wouldn't require duncan to find someone to drive to e.g. Litton (which you could walk, but would take some time).

Might check it out myself somewhen.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on April 07, 2010, 05:17:51 pm
The Eyre Arms in Hassop is good, open more now its summer too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on April 07, 2010, 05:46:37 pm
tis a bit on the expensive side though from what i remember. Looks well jackson when all that red ivy is popping.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on April 07, 2010, 05:54:38 pm
I've been to the Plough once, and didn't rate it. Proper gastro scene - over-priced, small portions, snotty staff.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on April 07, 2010, 06:00:57 pm
I've been to the Plough once, and didn't rate it. Proper gastro scene - over-priced, small portions, snotty staff.

That strikes it off my list then!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on April 07, 2010, 08:53:23 pm
The Barrel isn't far either, and is good for standard pub fare at standard prices, plus the best view in The Peak. Only been to the Sir William once and despite discouraging decor food and beer was very good. I may have written this before.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on April 09, 2010, 09:34:42 am
That would have been some time ago!  There's a range of very good reasons why virtually no one in Grindleford goes to the Sir William!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on June 21, 2010, 11:20:25 am
Based on this thread we went to the Yorkshire Bridge for lunch yesterday. It was great. Really nice food, the Copper Dragon 1816 is a lovely pint and the staff were all friendly and helpful. It was super busy being Father's Day and really nice weather but the food still didn't take too long to arrive (we were told 45 mins but it was only about 1/2 an hour). Not too pricey either. Highly recommended.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Offwidth on June 21, 2010, 04:36:41 pm
Roaches way...Lazy Trout, Meerborook and Ship Inn, Winkle always used to be good but havent been for a while. Travellors rest in Flash has just become a semi-themed pub but may be worth a try as they have cleaned everything and are looking at micro-brews. Wilkes Head in Leek was also recommended but I've never been.

In Glossup I nearly cried when Martin told me The Crown has lost its tennants and probably the great beer under £140 a pint and Thai food.

South-east peak seems always better than most areas of the peak so we only included some of the best in the Froggatt guide:

The Red Lion, Birchover; The Bear, Alderwasley, The Old Poets’ Corner with its own micro-brewery, is the best of a great set of pubs in Ashover; The Thorn Tree, Matlock; The Temple Hotel, Matlock Bath;  The Boat Inn, Cromford, The Jug and Glass in Lea (not as good as it was), The Barley Mow, Bonsall, The Blacks Head, Wirksworth; The Cliffe Inn, Crich; The Flying Childers, Stanton-in-the-Peak.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on June 21, 2010, 05:17:35 pm

In Glossup I nearly cried when Martin told me The Crown has lost its tennants and probably the great beer under £140 a pint



How much under £140 a pint? £138.61 under would make it a bargain.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: chris05 on July 10, 2010, 08:27:10 pm
Just been to the Old bowling Green in Winster, lovely place, with good beer and proper pub grub. It was really busy and we would have been turned away if we hadn't arrived as soon as they opened and sat outside. Makes a change for me to leave a pub in the peak and have actually enjoyed the food. ::)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on July 11, 2010, 06:46:46 pm
http://www.old-hall-inn.co.uk/ (http://www.old-hall-inn.co.uk/)

Lives up to its billing.

Really sound food, supreb ales and excellent staff, coupled with a great location this has to be a place to frequent.

Apparently it's a 15 minute walk from Chinley Station.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Falling Down on July 11, 2010, 07:30:37 pm
Why didn't you PM me you dick, it's less than 5 minutes from my house.

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Falling Down on July 11, 2010, 07:32:10 pm
Sloper's right though, The Old Hall just won CAMRA's "Best Pub In Derbyshire" and 'Best Seasonal Pub" award.

If any UKB regulars are heading this way, drop me a PM as it's my local.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on July 12, 2010, 11:33:23 am
You lucky bastard that place looks great. Kids welcome?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on July 12, 2010, 07:41:11 pm
Yes, kids were more than welcomed.

FD, you lucky luck bastard.

Will drop you a pm when we're having a break of freight.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Falling Down on July 13, 2010, 08:23:46 am
 :beer1:
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on October 02, 2010, 11:44:19 pm
Heading over to Chatsworth tomorrow with family and want to grab some food somewhere. Any recommendations pub wise in that direction? Any good places in Ashford in the Water?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on October 03, 2010, 07:02:02 am
Stopped in the Devonshire Arms (http://www.devonshirebeeley.co.uk/) on the way back from Cratcliffe the other week.  Didn't eat, but the beers were nice.  Menu looked good as did the dishes of others eating and I intend to check it out when in a similar situation to yourself.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: grumpycrumpy on October 03, 2010, 08:04:26 am
Stopped in the Devonshire Arms (http://www.devonshirebeeley.co.uk/) on the way back from Cratcliffe the other week.  Didn't eat, but the beers were nice.  Menu looked good as did the dishes of others eating and I intend to check it out when in a similar situation to yourself.

I've eaten there a couple of times ..... Food's excellent ....... Slightly pricey , but worth every penny ......
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on October 03, 2010, 12:36:27 pm
Looks nice but a bit pricey for today, will check it out another day. Thinking of trying the Bulls Head in Monyash.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 07, 2010, 10:07:39 pm
Can anyone point me to a peak boozer that pretty cozy, does badass grub but also does good but not too expensive accommodation, good breakfast, preferably somewhere nice etc? I got a mate in prison who's wedding anniversary is coming up etc etc.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on November 08, 2010, 09:34:59 pm
If you (or anyone you know) have the relevant Charity Unleashed voucher, you could try this (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,15471.msg284876.html#msg284876). We went for our anniversary. Think the voucher may be only for certain nights of the week?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 08, 2010, 10:00:20 pm
I don't have no charidy shit but will look into it anyway, sounds good etc. Cheers.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 08, 2010, 10:03:27 pm
Actually fuck that, they have a 2-night minimum stay on weekends, I'm strictly on an M-People vibe -  one night, one night, OOOOOh.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on November 08, 2010, 10:18:42 pm
Think the free room voucher was week nights only. I hear that you don't do weak nights.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 08, 2010, 10:30:59 pm
Or weak knights.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on November 22, 2010, 06:00:34 pm
any of these fine establishments allow pooch's in? (Not 'The Pooch').
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on November 23, 2010, 10:52:54 pm
any of these fine establishments allow pooch's in? (Not 'The Pooch').

to answer my own question: The Red Lion - Litton although for all new Dads they specify "No Babies!" on the website, and I was actually asked on the phone whether or not I had a baby when asking about the mini dog.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tommytwotone on December 14, 2010, 05:29:32 pm
Alright, anyone got any views on The Cricket Inn in Totley word?

Am coming down for a romantic weekend with the missus and this is just up the road. I was gonna take her to the Chequer's as it's one of my favourites but thought I'd try summat new.

Gonna take the recommendation from a few pages earlier for Rowley's as well for a bit of an early Xmas blowout.

Cheers all.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tommytwotone on December 15, 2010, 10:19:55 pm
Nobody? Fair enough...guess I'll post up a review once we've been then!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on December 16, 2010, 10:46:47 am
I'm sure it's been mentioned on here before somewhere.  :-\
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on December 16, 2010, 11:32:34 am
I had that inkling too, but was too lazy to search when I read the post.

Now I'm not so lazy, its mentioned three times in the Help! Sheffield restaurant recommendations needed - now please! (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9845) thread...

Here (2008) (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9845.msg161216/topicseen.html#msg161216)

Here (2010) (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9845.msg242103/topicseen.html#msg242103)

And here (2010) although more about the Cross Scythes on the main road (http://ukbouldering.com/board/index.php/topic,9845.msg259595/topicseen.html#msg259595)

I've stopped at the Cricket Inn for a pint (and puncture repair) after coming through Blacka Moor, beer was nice but pricey, menu looked fancy (and slightly more expensive to go with it, but the few meals looked to be home-made and not just reheated freezer fare).


Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: grumpycrumpy on December 16, 2010, 11:34:42 am
I've eaten there twice and found it a bit hit and miss .First time was enjoyable , quite memorable chips  , second not so , ...... Plus the food came on chopping boards , which is all well and good unless you've ordered summat with gravy    ....... The  beer was excellent  though , so that was nice  :beer2:   
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tommytwotone on December 16, 2010, 09:43:07 pm
Ahhh - had searched this thread and one of the others but forgot about the restaurant recommendations one...

We're (weather dependant) heading down tomorrow so will be doing Cricket Inn tomorrow, Rowley's on Sat. Will report back on findings, especially catering for the missus, who is veggie!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tlr on December 16, 2010, 10:35:57 pm
Rowleys is excellent, well worth the £15 taxi ride. I'm sure you'll enjoy it.

I agree with Grumpy about the cricket; generally ok but occasionally a bit disappointing. We have had a few unreasonably long waits for food.  :please:
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on February 05, 2011, 05:26:47 pm
We tried the Fox and Goose on 'Pudding Pie Hill' between curbar crossroads and Chesterfield. I'll be specific in a bit when I sit down, but to some it up:

The worst 'meal' I've been out for in as long as I can remember, never again.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Offwidth on February 06, 2011, 02:31:29 pm
Forgot to post a few weeks back. Lazy Trout has new managers. So far so good (still good beer and good food and climber friendly).
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on February 07, 2011, 10:03:40 am
We tried the Fox and Goose on 'Pudding Pie Hill' between curbar crossroads and Chesterfield. I'll be specific in a bit when I sit down, but to some it up:

The worst 'meal' I've been out for in as long as I can remember, never again.

Please elaborate!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on February 11, 2011, 12:10:30 am
Right, so - I'd previously looked at the website having spotted the signs on Baslow Road etc. and it gave the impression of a gastro pub, i.e cosy pub with decent food. And a couple of folk saying it was good, so we gave it a try.

Arrival - massive car park, rammed - which door? This is a massive boozer for a start.

Entry - you walk into what was obviously the old pub, but it has all the hallmarks of a chain - empty, cold, token fire at the far end, and a TV on the wall showing football.. hmmm. Anyway the young barman was a decent attentive chap, got the beers in and he suggested we take a seat, decide what we want o eat and then we'll get our table. There isn't actually a 'good' i.e. comfortable table in this whole 'pub' bit - and not really a lot on the menu to inspire.

Taking order 1 - woman comes out of a side door looking pissed off and asks for our order, by which time we've probably waited 40 mins, decided it's an atmosphere vacuum and wondering if the chinese is a more attractive option. We ask if there's a specials menu and to be seated before we order - and we are seated. Shown through to the 'dining room' which in reality is a corridor section between the pub bit and a massive conservatory style funtion room, in which a massive 65th birthday is taking place, with a terrible singer on absolutely blaring out Sinatra / Martin / Davis Jr etc. numbers at a volume that makes conversation a leaning forward so as to not shout kinda affair - all the while overlooked by staff rushing back and forth and the 'maitre d'' on a pedestal right next to us... sorry, more like a lectern....

Taking order 2 - maitre di - So, grim as it seems, we decide to press on, simply because by this time it's half nine and we haven't been out much lately (and the one good thing is the Peroni so I'm not objecting too much)
Anyway, this fellow looking like an spray tanned cross between Bradley Walsh and Tom Cruise off Cocktail swans over all 'Heey, how are you tonight my friends' with enough oil and slime to make the Gulf of Mexico look clean.

'Sorry for the wait, we're busy - been here before?'
'No, just passed by when we were walking nearby'
'Ah - just a sec' - walks off, we've alredy been waiting over an hour, and comes back with....

A FUCKING LEAFLET ABOUT WALKS NEAR THE PUB - THAT YOU CAN ORDER A PICNIC FROM THEM TO TAKE ALONG!!!!

Anyway, this is hurting me to recollect so I'll cut to the chase- I got a free pint for the delay but this cunt was straight out of a 'how to be a sleazy waiter' lesson - in fact my gyal even went to get her own coat just so he couldn't 'help her with it / himself to a quick grope' after the friendly hand on the shoulder earlier...

Food:
'Tartare sauce' = 'Catering salad cream'
Fish and Chips = the only thing on the menu she fancied, but a fucking scandal at £16
Lamb Shank = the only thing on the menu I thought they couldn't fuck up, well - 'Pommes Anna' were a. lumpy, b. burnt on the bottom from being kept hot on a tray in a round mould c. almost unpalatable due to the really bitter rosemary.
The gravy - out of a packet, undoubtedly - that artificial sticky/shiny 'setting' shit, salty and flavourless.
Veg - overcooked, dry, tough green beans

When we were obviously unhappy, and particularly when we didn't ask for a dessert, the oily cunt totally lost interest, and didn't even ask how the meal was - he gave us a card to fill in obviously we gave the shittest review, but it'll be no doubt binned.

Before it reaches the people who are blatantly the completely business oriented, profit oriented, not giving a fuck about providing a decent service, food or experience in what they portray as a traditional country pub, owners of this tragic, despicable excuse for .....

well, what the fuck is it? Don't ever, ever, waste your precious free time or money on these shameful parasites.

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on July 03, 2011, 03:13:24 pm
Heads up - checked out a pub today that had been under my radar for some reason (despite a peripheral mention early on this thread:

Derwentwater Arms, Calver. (http://www.derwentwaterarms.co.uk) Where the fuck is that I hear you say? Basically its about 100yards behind Outside, away from the main road crossroads. The food is absolutley knockout and not unreasonably priced, good ale too and nipper friendly. Best pub meal I've had in ages. Get to it.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: jfw on July 08, 2011, 11:12:11 am
Re: the cricket at totley

Was there fairly recently for mates birthday - I had lamb with minty mash and grilled cherry tomatoes - the lamb was ok-ish not special, the mash a bit tepid/uninspiring - the tomatoes really tasty - nothing seemed to really go together (and I', not some cordon bleu foody type - it was just a bit - meh!)

Stole some of other halfs chips they were really nice - your not really hitting your gastro pub targets if your chips are the nice thing IMO.

I would rather have something simpler done really well (like the home cooked Ham egg and chips at the red liion in litton) - than have "fancier" done a bit crappily.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on July 08, 2011, 01:15:24 pm
Quote
I would rather have something simpler done really well (like the home cooked Ham egg and chips at the red liion in litton) - than have "fancier" done a bit crappily

Amen to that. I thought the chips at The Cricket were disappointing. The only way you improve chips is with salt and vinegar, not by leaving the skins on or making them massive.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on July 08, 2011, 03:19:22 pm
The only way you improve chips is with salt and vinegar, not by leaving the skins on or making them massive.

Too right.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: nai on July 08, 2011, 05:23:35 pm
ate at the cricket last night (first time in ages) for the wife's birthday and the consensus was we should have saved ourself the walk and gone for a curry instead.   The pint of Cricketers to start and (overpriced if not on the Set Menu) cheese to finish were the only real good points.  Reckon the Cross Scythes round the corner is a better option.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Will Hunt on July 08, 2011, 07:07:08 pm
Went to the Bull's Head in Monyash (not a million miles away from Chee Dale) with parents yesterday. Simple but tasty pub food in a decent portion and at a fair price. We opted to sit outside where there is a very well kept beer garden with a kids adventure playground which made me jealous of the kids! the inside dining room looked very plush, more of a restaurant than a hotel. In fact it might have felt a little grandiose sitting in there. Some good beers on tap. Worth a visit.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on July 20, 2011, 01:26:59 pm
Went to the Bull's Head in Monyash (not a million miles away from Chee Dale) with parents yesterday. Simple but tasty pub food in a decent portion and at a fair price. We opted to sit outside where there is a very well kept beer garden with a kids adventure playground which made me jealous of the kids! the inside dining room looked very plush, more of a restaurant than a hotel. In fact it might have felt a little grandiose sitting in there. Some good beers on tap. Worth a visit.

Good arrows Will. That adventure playground looks a winner for keeping the sprogs happy.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on November 07, 2011, 07:39:45 pm
Is there anywhere along the Monsal trail worth stopping off for food/drink?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Snoops on November 07, 2011, 07:56:03 pm
Is there anywhere along the Monsal trail worth stopping off for food/drink?

Monsal Head Hotel, is pretty average at best, avoid if possible.
Unfortunately I can't think of anything great thats next to the trail. Take a picnic and sit by the ducks in Chee Dale?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 07, 2011, 10:41:16 pm
anglers at millers dale? always been good pub grub when I've been there. they have a walkers/sweaty cyclists room too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: RopeBoy on November 07, 2011, 11:52:15 pm
After catching up with this thread and a couple of recent experiences I'm tempted to stop eating in pubs in the Peak, from now on will stop for a beer and either eat at home or order a curry as we leave the pub which should be more or less ready when we get there and will have cost quarter of the price and will be less disappointing!

The missus is getting pretty handy with the slow cooker, popped it on before we go out and returned to house smelling of nice food and all we had to do was dish up, result!

J :-)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on November 08, 2011, 01:33:33 pm
Or just have a steak pie in the Grouse with a pint of pedigree. Every one a winner.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: RopeBoy on November 08, 2011, 03:10:03 pm
Yeah, the Grouse is okay when Nigel is cooking/chef not so keen when the other chap is cooking.

J :2thumbsup:
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: T_B on November 08, 2011, 04:09:58 pm
After catching up with this thread and a couple of recent experiences I'm tempted to stop eating in pubs in the Peak

I know what you mean, but I've been to the Derwent Arms in Calver for food twice recently (based on Dave's recommendation - above). I reckon it's a bit of a hidden gem. Bloody marvelous pie and chips and a top notch Sunday roast. Excellent beer. Can't think of anywhere better in the Peak that I've been to in recent years...
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on March 16, 2012, 03:09:44 pm
Insightful piece on the decline of UK Pubs (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/video/2012/mar/16/pub-closures-pubcos-landlords-punch-video).
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on March 16, 2012, 07:59:55 pm
Heads up on the Derwentwater Arms - I heard that the proprietors (i.e. the people running it on the dates of the previous posts) were moving, and they have - now at the Angel at Holmesfield (http://www.angelatholmesfield.co.uk/)

Not been to either so both may be excellent now.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on March 16, 2012, 08:11:14 pm
We went to the DA at the end of jan, it was still good - have they moved since then do you reckon?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on March 16, 2012, 08:23:23 pm
I just spoke to the dude, December he said... so the Angel needs testing to see if they carried the quality over
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on March 19, 2012, 10:09:38 pm
Just back from the Derwentwater Arms and it was excellent, 3 courses, 5 different dishes in total all very good, the Chatsworth Gold was also going down very well. Tonight was the 'other chef' too (i.e. not 'Alan' who stayed on after the last proprietors left). Good service too, so all in all we'll be going back.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Paul B on March 26, 2012, 10:39:46 pm
As I should have posted here to start with...

Lazy trout, meerbrook. Owner is chef/cook. Proper homemade great pub food. Excellent value too. Good beers. Friendly. Fire in winter. Dogs fine. (Paul - am duplicating fb message here as this pub deserves UKB custom - best pub food near roaches i reckon).

Ate here Sunday night and it was exactly how Jamie describes...

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: jamiev on March 28, 2012, 05:01:51 pm
As I should have posted here to start with...

Lazy trout, meerbrook. Owner is chef/cook. Proper homemade great pub food. Excellent value too. Good beers. Friendly. Fire in winter. Dogs fine. (Paul - am duplicating fb message here as this pub deserves UKB custom - best pub food near roaches i reckon).

Ate here Sunday night and it was exactly how Jamie describes...

Glad it lived up to expectations / my hyperbolic description! Must visit there again soon myself.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on June 27, 2012, 11:58:23 am
The Samuel Fox, Bradwell

Ate here for our anniversary on Saturday based on a prior recommendation. Wish I had ignored it, however since she reckons I rant too much I'll borrow the wife's tripadvisor review:
Quote
My husband and I have just returned from an extremely poor evening meal at The Samuel Fox. First impressions were good, the venue is pleasant enough and the views amazing. The menu choices were also very good, plenty of choice and some innovative sounding combinations. The problems commenced with the starters. When mine arrived the presentation was first class but it somehow managed to be completely tasteless! The crab cakes were really potato cakes although I did see crab in them and the scallops, although perfectly cooked just tasted of the griddle they had been cooked on. The accompanying sauce was completely bland. Meanwhile, on the table of 6 adjacent to us there were problems with cold mash and meals being returned to the kitchen, hmmmm. On to mains then with trepidation .My Husband's pork was very good and the sauce had a great flavour but the mash was lumpy. My hake then arrived and although cooked to perfection, the saffron mash was overpowering and cold and lumpy. It was replaced with apologies but having had two back previoulsy I thought this was totally unacceptable and sloppy attention to detail. The shellfish sauce was so scanty it was difficult to ascertain what it actually tasted of. Vegetables have to be ordered separately and if you forget there is no prompt from the waiter to remind you; when ours finally arrived my husband had finished his dinner. Like the table of six next to us we had lost total confidence in the food and passed on dessert; I have never eaten out at a fine dining establishment and not at least looked at the dessert menu. Overall I was terribly disappointed with the food and this is not a cheap place to eat. Cold, lumpy mash on a £15.00 course? I wouldn't serve that on a weekday meal! Would not recommend and would not return.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on July 15, 2012, 05:50:15 pm
Been to the Angler's Rest in millers dale today, the one on the turnoff for the Tor. Not been for uears but to my relief its still good solid unfussy trad pub food, nice ales and a very friendly staff especially welcoming to kids. Barmaid had an impressive 24" afro which is worth the drive in itself.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bubba on July 15, 2012, 06:34:17 pm
Not quite Peak but close.

Went to the Devonshire Arms at Middle Handley (http://www.devonshirearmsmiddlehandley.com/) for Sunday lunch a few weeks ago.  It's was voted as best restaurant and best gastro pub last year by Eat Sheffield (http://www.eatsheffield.com).

It's not really pub grub, it's full-on gastro - you wouldn't go here for a pint. But anyway, the food we had was really good, the place is pleasant and it wasn't stupidly spenny.


Back to your traditional pub-grub, we went to the Barrel Inn at Brettton (http://www.thebarrelinn.co.uk/) last weekend, perfect if you've been out at Stoney, WCJ, etc.  Proper old pub with a decent pint, solid trad pub lunch and fantastic views over the White Peak. 
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Tommy on July 15, 2012, 07:16:58 pm
Not quite Peak but close.

Went to the Devonshire Arms at Middle Handley (http://www.devonshirearmsmiddlehandley.com/) for Sunday lunch a few weeks ago.  It's was voted as best restaurant and best gastro pub last year by Eat Sheffield (http://www.eatsheffield.com).

It's not really pub grub, it's full-on gastro - you wouldn't go here for a pint. But anyway, the food we had was really good, the place is pleasant and it wasn't stupidly spenny.


Yeah I went there a few weeks go on a recommendation. It was good, although I was expecting a bit better considering how highly it was voted. Maybe that we me being naive though. Go for starters over puddings - better flavours.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on July 15, 2012, 07:51:46 pm
Been to the Angler's Rest in millers dale today, the one on the turnoff for the Tor. Not been for uears but to my relief its still good solid unfussy trad pub food, nice ales and a very friendly staff especially welcoming to kids. Barmaid had an impressive 24" afro which is worth the drive in itself.

Had a quick glance down that way today while I was doing some X-treme, X-railway, passenger laden, off-road spouse racing on The Mighty Monsal Trail.

Couldn't see her Afro.

I will agitate for a closer view next weekend.

Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: underground on March 05, 2013, 06:51:07 pm
The Bowling Green, Bradwell
This is my after caving boozer and all I normally manage is a pint, scratchings and if the bingo or quiz is on, free sarnies and (the best) roast spuds.
I took my daughter on her first trip caving in Saturday so we had to complete the experience and go for lunch.

All I can say is blooming awesome- no fancy work, just proper pub grub in pleasant surroundings. I had the 'Desperate Dan' steak and ale pie, in a pie dish 9" square, full of meat, lovely rich gravy and a short homemade pastry. The chips were more like thrice cooked roasties of Tuesday night legend. Ace. They also do a 'cow calf' ie smaller one for more modest appetites.

Everything else on the menu was tempting so ill be back.

Recommended
Title: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on March 05, 2013, 07:22:13 pm
Fuck that sounds well brown, cheers for the heads up.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on March 05, 2013, 09:18:41 pm
Forgot to mention, a bunch of us had a meal in the royal oak a few weeks back, between Monyash and Longnor at the end of the old railway/ cycle track. Very good food, and very accommodating of a big party turning up unannounced with a bunch of noisy kids. Worth checking out on the way back from the Roaches.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Hydraulic Man on June 29, 2013, 10:49:16 am
Agree about the Royal Oak. Meals look massive and the ale was well kept. The next village heading towards Longnor has a smashing pub with beer garden and good beer. Packhorse in Crowdicote.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on September 17, 2013, 09:25:40 pm
Own a piece of a peak district pub http://www.bcs.hopevalleyderbyshire.co.uk/ (http://www.bcs.hopevalleyderbyshire.co.uk/)
Title: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Eddies on September 17, 2013, 09:45:52 pm
The royal oak is the biz, big farmers dinners and its all great... No starter required!
Buxton brewery have just last week opened a bar in town called the tap house serving around a dozen of their own ales on tap and hundreds of bottled beers from around the world.. The foods really good also!
(http://img.tapatalk.com/d/13/09/18/y3yvu3um.jpg)
Title: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on October 12, 2013, 05:14:32 pm
One from last weekend: The Stag on psalter lane, sheff. Thornbridge run place now, good beer, we went for sunday lunch with 2 kids. Place was busy but not too bad. Food was very good and reasonably priced. However, the service was glacially slow, basically the kitchen is about half the size it needs to be for that size of pub. So go there for food but not when its busy or if you're in a rush.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: horn on October 26, 2013, 11:50:30 pm
Glad I've discovered this thread, gonna be checking back through eagerly. I've just moved up here and I was under the impression that there were no decent pubs in the whole of the Peak District. Turns out there are, but the good ones aren't necessarily in the best locations for crags. One thing I have noticed (and this is a very broad generalisation) is that Peak District bar staff are a bit more reluctant to top up a foamy pint than I'm used to.

Until I've had a proper read back and explore, here's some brief opinions:


Little John aka "LJ's" - utter shite

Millstone - mediocre food, acceptable pint. don't get the dog snacks they sell in little bags on the bar mistaken for Jerky.

Scotsman's Pack - nice pint from mainstream breweries. not eaten there yet. It's alright.

Norfolk arms - nice pint shit food.

Fox house - another one of Vintage Inns depressing faux country pubs. yawn.

Broady - good beer, good whisky, really nice pork pie accompaniments (but no jelly round the pie..wtf?) Disgraceful food.

Cricket Inn -  really really well kept ale, good food (seems pricey for a pub, but the portions are decent). Serious chips. Does seem a bit pretentious.

Barrel Inn - Uninspiring and brief selection of ales, but what they had was well kept. Food is really tasty and generous portions, but oddly presented (my venison with mashed parsnip came garnished with a sprig of parsley, a rosemary stalk and some artfully trimmed pieces of tomato, reminiscent of a thai restaurant trying to be fancy. Otherwise, I really like it!

The Moon - absolutely the worst pub I have ever visited in my entire life. Dreadful in every way you can think of.


I guess peoples opinions of what makes a good pub vary wildly. Mine does too. There's a lot of variables interacting intangibly. Obviously quality of booze is the most important factor, decor and ambiance comes into it a bit, food less so (but not to be discounted). Can't explain why I liked the Barrel so much, it just 'felt' right.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: lagerstarfish on October 27, 2013, 07:41:59 am
can someone let horn know that dense is using his login
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: fried on October 27, 2013, 07:53:37 am
Can't be, there's grammar, punctuation and everything. The words r even spelt out in full.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: fatboySlimfast on October 27, 2013, 07:54:36 am
The moon has been shit for years, met the new landlord last night in the local shop who claimed it was greatly improved. Will have a wander down later
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: a dense loner on October 27, 2013, 09:04:00 am
Fuckers.
Talking about dog food in pubs? Dogs shouldn't be allowed in pubs.
Title: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tomtom on October 27, 2013, 09:27:58 am
Could some one tell Dense that his account has been taken over by Horn - theres punctuation and even CAPs... ;)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: a dense loner on October 27, 2013, 12:39:21 pm
 That's weird. It's the new OS on the iPad, you nearly had me.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on March 23, 2014, 07:37:20 pm
Tasty food in the Barrel today. Worth booking on a weekend as gets very busy with the OAP crowd. Amazing position on a clear day. Friendly staff, made us feel welcome despite not booking and having lively kids. Decent sized pudding portions, almost big enough to share and justify the £5 price.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: SamT on March 31, 2014, 10:30:03 pm

Been meaning to give the Anglers Rest in Bamford a shout out.

http://anglers.bamford.coop/ (http://anglers.bamford.coop/)

It was successfully snatched from under the noses of developers who'd actually bought it from the brewers by the local community who've been busy reviving.  They've split it so its half pub (on the left) half cafe on the right, and the local postoffice has moved to the middle.

I've not eaten in the pub side yet, but have stopped for a butty/soup in the cafe half and its very pleasant - kind of longlands esque.  They've got plans to develop the rest of it too including the possibility of a bunkhouse which is in existence, tucked away at the left hand end but not used.

One important thing to note is that there is loads of parking round the back, which is important because I think many folks (including  myself) just whizz by on the main road and your past it before you've thought about it.

I'd be interested to eat in the pub side.  Anyone been ??
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: tomtom on April 01, 2014, 04:24:12 am
Good knowledge Sam.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: shurt on February 23, 2015, 08:18:53 pm
Any tips for a good pub pub i.e. non gastro, non chain in the peak? Am in and around Grindleford. Don't mind a bit of a drive.
Is the Anglers worth the trip?
Ta
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: sidewinder on February 23, 2015, 08:24:30 pm
Derwentwater Arms in Calver
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Sloper on February 23, 2015, 08:34:28 pm
If that's the one by the cross roads then agree
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on February 23, 2015, 11:17:47 pm

Any tips for a good pub pub i.e. non gastro, non chain in the peak? Am in and around Grindleford. Don't mind a bit of a drive.
Is the Anglers worth the trip?
Ta

Anglers in Millers Dale always been good when I've been in. Otherwise, head to the Grouse.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on February 24, 2015, 10:27:29 am
Plus the Druid in Birchover, and the Royal Oak in Hurdlow, both worth the extra drive.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: shurt on February 24, 2015, 11:00:09 am
Thanks all, will report back later.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: SamT on February 24, 2015, 03:27:08 pm
red lion in litton shirley ought to be high on the list.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: shurt on February 25, 2015, 01:49:59 pm
derwentwater arms not bad but not the best. really lovely friendly staff but only bass and doom bar and no food on. it was a no chip end to the day....
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: seankenny on April 04, 2015, 01:49:58 pm
Has anyone been to the Yorkshire Bridge Inn, Bamford? Staying in Bamford for my mum's 70th birthday and looking for somewhere that does good food and isn't too far away. Not fussed about the beer.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: bigtuboflard on April 04, 2015, 07:19:44 pm
Not been in for years but ok the last time I went. There is the Ladybower Inn too which again last time I went in was decent enough standard pub food. Presume it's to take your mum out for food too? I'd also recommend Maazi in Hathersage though it's a curry house and I know the old folk aren't always keen on curry. They do a free minibus shuttle service from at least as far as Bamford though so need need to drive. Nicely done out inside too if you want to get in the good books


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Offwidth on August 25, 2015, 11:12:09 am
Not really Peak but found this really friendly place at the weekend (part of a trend of converting shops into real ale joints) and its well worth a visit and only a minutes walk from Cheadle Hulme railway station.

http://www.thechivertontap.co.uk
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: mrjonathanr on August 25, 2015, 09:28:41 pm
Pointing Dog in Bakewell. Good food and service, child friendly. Cheaper than it's sister restaurant in Stockport too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Jaspersharpe on September 04, 2015, 11:56:43 am
Any recommendations in / near Matlock?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on September 04, 2015, 12:42:12 pm
Is The Druid at Birchover close enough to Matlock?
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Bubba on September 04, 2015, 08:13:28 pm
Went to the Druid the other day...been many times before but not for ages.

Cozy venue, solid range of quality ales (CAMRA award winning boozer), comprehensive & interesting menu.

Shame the food was overcooked and dry. Waitress and barmaid seemed rushed off their feet and this was mid-week lunchtime (though to be fair was very busy).

Suspect it'd be much better outside of the school holidays. I want to like the place as I've had such great food there in the past.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: ChrisC on September 05, 2015, 10:26:43 am
In town Moca is great for beer. Not food though.

The Boat in cromford is good for food and beer. Ashover has The Old Poets Corner with its own brewery. The White Lion in Starkholmes above High Tor is also worth a look and handy parking for the crag on a busy day.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Hydraulic Man on September 05, 2015, 02:26:04 pm
If your in the Wirksworth area try the Barley Bow in Kirk Ireton. Beer from a jug, no food or other distractions. 4 proper ales straight from the barrel (no taps)

2 ladies behind the bar can be a bit 'blunt' to say the least but is an experience none the less. Probably best enjoyed in the winter with a big fire and someone else driving.....The Hartington IPA comes recommended.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: fried on September 05, 2015, 03:50:26 pm
Three stags head in Darley dale was my top find in May. Good beer, super friendly, I only had a sandwich and some curly fries as a snack but it was a helping and cheap. Nice garden too, although we were inside.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Hydraulic Man on February 14, 2016, 06:39:38 pm
Moon at Stoney has been refurbed and serves a decent pint. Was packed and the food is allegedly very good.

More importantly and signalling the start of a Peak Limestone trad renaissance this summer Tom Proctor is back on the wall next to the dart board looking like he still might pull into the groove on Menopause without blowing his tendons.

He's been hiding in someones house the last few years...........
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on February 21, 2016, 09:05:32 pm
Another spot on visit to the Royal Oak at Hurdlow. Catered for 21 of us inc 10 kids after a wet and windy stint on the Tissington trail. Fab roasts came out fast, fresh and hot. Proper portions. Great beer. Kids meals decent at sensible prices. Open fires.  :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Dolly on September 06, 2016, 09:41:45 pm
I went to The Maynard Arms in Grindleford for the second time today.
It was the best meal I've had this year bar none.
Very friendly, great service and good value. We were on a planning day with work in a lovely art deco furnished room.
We ate outside and nothing was too much trouble including a couple of unasked for but lovely lemon sorbets between courses
I'm already planning when to go again


http://www.themaynard.co.uk/restaurant/our-menus#1471881071526-1d38b1e0-c189
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: haydn jones on November 08, 2016, 07:51:45 pm
I've  got family visiting this sunday and was wondering wheres best to go for sunday lunch. I was thinkimg one of the peak pubs sheffield side i.e fox house, the grouse, chequers inn ect never been to any of them. Was hoping for some peoples advoce on which pub is the best on this side of the peak
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Duncan campbell on November 09, 2016, 08:33:57 am
Grouse is pretty good. But it's also the only one I've been too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on November 09, 2016, 09:09:49 am
A good source of peak pub recommendations is the 7 pages of forum posts directly preceding Haydn's post.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Johnny Brown on November 09, 2016, 09:50:14 am
Fox house and Dore moor are part of the same chain and reliable, although they tend to occasionally lurch disastrously towards trying to be more gastro e.g. six giant chips stacked as a log cabin. Grouse is old school pub grub, limited and arguably dated menu but they do it well and it's family run. Norfolk arms is a bit variable, was good last time I ate there but landlord reputedly a bit of a dick. Millstone is ok, not as good as it was a few years back. If you are cheap and hungry hit up the Moorlands at Owler bar, it's like a Wetherspoons with a view, big carvery for a fiver.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: slackline on November 09, 2016, 09:52:22 am
I went to The Maynard Arms in Grindleford for the second time today.
It was the best meal I've had this year bar none.
Very friendly, great service and good value.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: haydn jones on November 09, 2016, 10:21:29 am
Cheers guys thanks for in input. Given me a few options :)
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: SamT on November 09, 2016, 10:22:56 am
Was at the Plough in Hathersage recently in the evening recently for a meal.  Bit over priced I'd say.  The food was OK, nothing wrong per se,  but certainly not worth the money we paid for it.

Cricketers in Dore?? (I've never actually been in!)
On a similar note, whats the Peacock at Owler Bar like these days??
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: nai on November 09, 2016, 10:32:16 am
If you are cheap and hungry hit up the Moorlands at Owler bar, it's like a Wetherspoons with a view, big carvery for a fiver.

It's a fiver Mon-Sat, the price rockets to almost £8 on a Sunday (although kids get free food so works out the same for families). Still a better Sunday lunch and better value than the Peacock or Cross Scythes in the immediate vicinity though.  Go there quite a bit, the kids love it - £4 for meat and veg that they wolf down then go back for seconds vs double that for a plate of pasta just because it comes with a baloon.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: nai on November 09, 2016, 10:41:14 am
Cricketers in Dore?? (I've never actually been in!)

The Crown just down the road now does good food at a fraction of the cost. Proper home made stuff - pies, chips made from potatoes, even the kids pizzas and fish fingers are homemade.  Used to have a bad rep for not being very welcoming but has changed hands a few times, you can even prderat your table now.

On a similar note, whats the Peacock at Owler Bar like these days??

Only ever been once for Sunday dinner and would just go to the Moorlands instead.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: T_B on November 09, 2016, 10:42:44 am

On a similar note, whats the Peacock at Owler Bar like these days??

I went with the family over half term. The service was very good (though it was early/quiet) and personally I like the big room; it doesn't feel crammed and has some nice old beams. Anyway, the food was fine for chain pub food, kids meals were pretty good. Mrs T_B was unimpressed that the 'twice cooked' chips were not home made. It's nicer than the similarly-priced Wheatsheaf in Baslow, but without the play area (not an issue at this time of year). I had a good pint of Landlord. They serve food all day, unlike a lot of places that don't do food until 6pm, which is why we ended up there.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on November 09, 2016, 05:47:57 pm
Can't remember if it's been mentioned, despite not quite being in the Peak! (only by about 200m), the Nags Head near Damflask reservoir does a stunning pie, peas, chips and pint deal. It's a Bradfield Brewery pub so the beer is first class. Haven't had a Sunday roast there but if the quality of the pie is typical then it will be great.

Menus etc
http://bradfieldbrewery.com/the-nags-head/
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Duma on November 09, 2016, 07:26:51 pm
Went to the red Lion in Litton on Saturday, decent pint, amazing slow cooked blade of beef, board games, fires in three rooms. Were happy to delay our dinner while we finished scrabble, really enjoyed it.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Dolly on November 09, 2016, 08:44:25 pm
Can't remember if it's been mentioned, despite not quite being in the Peak! (only by about 200m), the Nags Head near Damflask reservoir does a stunning pie, peas, chips and pint deal. It's a Bradfield Brewery pub so the beer is first class. Haven't had a Sunday roast there but if the quality of the pie is typical then it will be great.

Menus etc
http://bradfieldbrewery.com/the-nags-head/ (http://bradfieldbrewery.com/the-nags-head/)


Its worth going there just for the beer. It tastes like nectar from the brewery just up the road and its dead cheap. I've ridden there from work a few times and I don't think the food is that great TBH, but the portions were massive
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: dave on January 15, 2017, 06:24:02 pm
Can't remember if it's been mentioned, despite not quite being in the Peak! (only by about 200m), the Nags Head near Damflask reservoir does a stunning pie, peas, chips and pint deal. It's a Bradfield Brewery pub so the beer is first class. Haven't had a Sunday roast there but if the quality of the pie is typical then it will be great.

Menus etc
http://bradfieldbrewery.com/the-nags-head/


Went here today, great cheap beer and knockout no-pissing-around pub food with proper Yorkshire portions. Steak and Ale pie easily as good as the pie at The Grouse but a few quid cheaper, MILES better proper handmade chips AND you get a pint with it. Deffo a proper locals pub, i.e. middle of the day on a Sunday and there's tons of lads stood in there all day boozing and playing snooker, so you probably wouldn't go for a fancy meal type thing, but otherwise can't really fault it. Only got about 4 tables to sit and eat at so you wanna book or phone ahead.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: the_dom on March 14, 2017, 07:30:45 pm
Any recommendations, good people of UKB, for someone staying in Hathersage and then Sheffield? Pubs and I get on pretty well..
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Obi-Wan is lost... on March 14, 2017, 10:56:27 pm
Any recommendations, good people of UKB, for someone staying in Hathersage and then Sheffield? Pubs and I get on pretty well..

I think the Scotsmans Pack (http://www.scotsmanspackcountryinn.co.uk/) is probably the best for food in Hathersage, Millstone (http://www.millstoneinn.co.uk/) is reliable, good carverys but not amazing. (Haven't been regularly for a while so may have upped it's game). Little John (http://www.littlejohnhotel.co.uk/) was always standard pub fare, massive portions but pretty average, but again I may be out of date. We have eaten at the one on the way to Grindleford, it was ok but quite pricey from memory. Edit: The Plough (http://www.theploughinn-hathersage.co.uk/) is on the way to Grindleford and it is still pricey!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: the_dom on March 15, 2017, 02:59:34 am
Any recommendations, good people of UKB, for someone staying in Hathersage and then Sheffield? Pubs and I get on pretty well..

I think the Scotsmans Pack (http://www.scotsmanspackcountryinn.co.uk/) is probably the best for food in Hathersage, Millstone (http://www.millstoneinn.co.uk/) is reliable, good carverys but not amazing. (Haven't been regularly for a while so may have upped it's game). Little John (http://www.littlejohnhotel.co.uk/) was always standard pub fare, massive portions but pretty average, but again I may be out of date. We have eaten at the one on the way to Grindleford, it was ok but quite pricey from memory. Edit: The Plough (http://www.theploughinn-hathersage.co.uk/) is on the way to Grindleford and it is still pricey!

Awesome, thanks!
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: deacon on March 15, 2017, 05:08:01 am
Pubs in Hathersage are a bit shit for food, but both curry houses are above average.
The little one for an old school curry, or Mazzis  for a posh curry.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: mark20 on July 25, 2018, 12:17:45 pm
Was pleasantly surprised by the food in the Scotsmans Pack the other week. Great slab of gammon steak. The roast pork 'sandwhich', was small roast dinner between two slabs of fresh bread, all soaked in gravy - it looked amazing.

Maazi is the go-to curry house for me in Hathersage now. But bare in mind everything is a bit spicey for the grade
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: Wood FT on July 25, 2018, 02:32:40 pm
Was pleasantly surprised by the food in the Scotsmans Pack the other week. Great slab of gammon steak. The roast pork 'sandwhich', was small roast dinner between two slabs of fresh bread, all soaked in gravy - it looked amazing.

Maazi is the go-to curry house for me in Hathersage now. But bare in mind everything is a bit spicey for the grade

Beta
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: bigironhorse on July 25, 2018, 03:32:53 pm
Was pleasantly surprised by the food in the Scotsmans Pack the other week. Great slab of gammon steak. The roast pork 'sandwhich', was small roast dinner between two slabs of fresh bread, all soaked in gravy - it looked amazing.

Maazi is the go-to curry house for me in Hathersage now. But bare in mind everything is a bit spicey for the grade

I've had a few good curries at Sangam's in the past but last time I went all the food was so oily as to be nearly inedible. Naan bread crap too. Will try out Maazi next time.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: sdm on July 25, 2018, 10:22:34 pm
Maazi have a second place in Matlock that is decent too.
Title: Re: Peak Pubs - booze & grub
Post by: El Mocho on July 28, 2018, 09:44:49 am
Was pleasantly surprised by the food in the Scotsmans Pack the other week. Great slab of gammon steak. The roast pork 'sandwhich', was small roast dinner between two slabs of fresh bread, all soaked in gravy - it looked amazing.

Maazi is the go-to curry house for me in Hathersage now. But bare in mind everything is a bit spicey for the grade

John Parsons - the guy who was the chief/owner at 'The Kitchen' in Sheffield is currently the chief at the Scotsmans and I've had reports from a few people that it's been good there recently.
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2024, SimplePortal